I’m fairly certain that 85% of the people I know have come to accept that I have an unhealthy obsession with Girls, this small HBO show written, directed, and starring a talentless girl named Lena Dunham. Clearly, sarcasm.
I’m pretty obsessed with Dunham’s work, her outlook, and what she has achieved by the age of 26. Also, she’s dating Jack Antonoff of Fun., which I think is pretty cute. (Did you see how excited she was when they won the Best New Artist award at the Grammy’s? I thought Frank Ocean should’ve taken it, but still, cute.)
Anyway. Last season, I was absolutely captivated. The show was such an accurate reflection of my life that it was sometimes uncomfortable to watch. The series just felt refreshingly true to life. I know Dunham has taken a lot of criticism for writing a series that was very specific to her experience (i.e. entitlement, race), but as someone struggling with post-grad existence, I could very much identify with it. For the record, I had definitely identified with Season One Hannah.
I will probably rave more about Girls as a series at a later date, but for now, a few quick thoughts on season two so far. Spoilers ahead, maybe.
1. Hannah. She’s more annoying this season, and it really didn’t affect me before. In reading various interviews where Dunham talks about her character, I’ve better come to undertand that Hannah often approaches sex as if she’s an outside character to her life. This season especially, I feel like she’s making a lot of choices only so she can write about them later. I know this is central to her character, but these choices are becoming far more haphazard and questionable to me. Believe me when I say I’m not slut-shaming, I just feel like a girl who is super concerned about the stuff that comes out from the sides of condoms (did anyone ever solve that?!?) would be more hesitant. Or, maybe I just miss her relationship with Adam.
2. Adam. Prior to tonight’s episode, I thought I just missed “Season One Adam,” but I think I just miss when he wasn’t sad and depressed about Hannah. (AA speech = gold though.) Last season, he was this strange character that both compelled me and confused me until the party episode where everything was turned around. And then I loved him. I wanted an Adam. I still do. He’s completely messed up, and super strange, but that’s part of the appeal. I don’t remember where I read it, but somewhere on the interwebs last year, he was referred to as Manic-Pixie-Dream-Big, referencing how simultaneously great and messed up Mr. Big of Sex and the City could be. I’m hoping he gets more episodes like the one that aired tonight, because he’s something I definitely miss from season one.
3. Shoshanna. And Ray. They are the best. The subway scene is arguably one of my favourites this season and kind of renewed my faith in the writing. They have a really great dynamic between them that works really well. I questioned it last season, because Ray just came off as an asshole, but I’m enjoying them together. It’s not perfect, but I think that’s a great thing. They are both very refreshing in their own way. And also, Ray’s cartographer/explorer pep talk to Marnie this past episode was a total highlight.
4. I like that Marnie is struggling. I’m really enjoying it, and as weird as the thought would have been last season, I’m identifying with her most. I can relate to her character feeling lost for once. She’s used to having a plan, and is uncomfortable with instability so she’s flailing a little in every aspect of her life. Even last season, I saw Marnie as the most realistic character (re: relationship with Charlie), but the hardest to like. This season, I’m understanding where she’s coming from better.
5. Generally speaking, I feel like this season is hitting just a little bit of a “sophomore slump.” After all the praise, criticism and overall media attention it got last year, it’s taking a bit for it come into it’s own and decide what it’s going to be for the long haul. I’m finding myself truly enjoying about every other episode as opposed to every single episode, and I’m less certain about my undying love for the series. But, I’m hopeful, and that counts for something.
(P.S. I wish Donald Glover’s role lasted longer. I wish Elijah’s role had been shorter.)